by Tracy McCue, Sumner Newscow — Sumner County Planning Commission Director Jon Bristor, upon the direction of two Sumner County Commissioners, is asking for the removal of two mobile homes off of property owned by Lynda and James Lynn Davis at 1101 North Line Street — just two blocks north of the Belle Plaine city limits.Bristor said he has spoken with Ms. Davis this morning giving her and her brother 30 days to remove two mobile homes off a .8 acre lot in unincorporated Sumner County. Bristor said he will also submit a formal letter to the owners. If the Davis family does not comply, the county could take the matter to court, Bristor said.Bristor said the Davis family is violating three Sumner County ordinances: •moving a pre-1976 manufactured home into the unincorporated Sumner County limits;•not obtaining a certified transportation permit;•and having two mobile homes on one parcel of property.The steps taken by the Sumner Planning and Zoning Commission office today came after a contentious 70 minute discussion held at the Sumner County Commissioners meeting Monday. Two of the commissioners ultimately decided to have Bristor make the enforcements, while another commissioner said the county should not be involved with the mobile home issue.The issue arose when the owners of “Triple 5” mobile home park, who are allegedly from California, decided to close down its operation in the summer of 2012, Lynda Davis said. The Davises were occupants at the park and owned two pre-1976 mobile homes. Lynda Davis said they were given 60 days notice to move their mobile homes off the property. James Davis told Sumner Newscow that their mobile homes were the only ones occupied at the time, and there are still abandoned mobile homes at the mobile home park site today.The Davises were taking care of their mother, Georgie Davis at the time. In November, Lynda Davis bought the parcel north of Belle Plaine, and moved the mobile homes there. Georgia died Dec. 3, 2012. She said they made the move so they could continue to take care of their ailing mother before her death.The move, however, was illegal and Bristor said he had received a complaint by neighbors on Nov. 26, 2012. The neighbors’ concerns were also brought up at two commissioners meetings in 2012. They instructed Bristor to take the matter to the advisory Sumner County Planning Commission to interpret the law concerning moving pre-1976 mobile homes. The commission, in turn, voted 8-3 at its Jan. 16 meeting that the ordinance was legal and should be enforced.Bristor then brought his findings back to the commissioners on Monday where a lengthy and contentious discussion ensued. Six neighboring property owners, including Kelly and Kim Martin of Belle Plaine, were at Monday’s meeting. Kim Martin sent a letter via e-mail to Sumner Newscow expressing her concerns as well.She and her husband had bought rural property in the area in March 2012 and moved to Sumner County the letter said.“There was no ‘squatter’s’ mobile home park developing near us. It was actually already in existence at the south end of Belle Plaine,” Kim Martin said in the letter. “But in November 2012, what resembled as a ‘squatter’s mobile home park’ began to develop in the township. This became a concern to me for it was an entrance to my and several other properties, no matter which direction you drove, you drove past it.”She said the inclusion of these two mobile homes is causing her property values to decrease.On Monday, the Commissioners were not in agreement with one another. District 1 Commissioner Steve Warner advocated that the Davis family should be left alone, citing that the Davis were being deprived of their Fifth Amendment right of the U.S. Constitution which states that citizens are protected against the abuse of government authority in a legal procedure.Commissioner Jim Newell disagreed, stating that laws are in place and throwing out the rules for one incident is not good governmental policy. If the commissioners were to eliminate the pre-1976 mobile home ordinance it would only cause expansive county government, he said.Commissioner Cliff Bales said the ordinance should be changed in which pre-1976 mobile homes could be allowed to move within the county but not from another county into Sumner. But in this case with the law already on the book it should be enforced. He requested that the planning commission revisit the ordinance again and see if it could to be changed.One planning commission board member John Larsen was in attendance at the Commissioners meeting and vocally supported the enforcement of the law.“If we don’t enforce the zoning laws, then why do we have a planning commission or even have these laws on the books?” Larsen said.The neighbors in attendance speculated that the ordinance change could be a way for the commissioners to cater to the oil industry and its possible influx of workers coming to the county who will need housing. Others worry by getting rid of the ordinance, that would invite a glut of mobile homes coming from small towns such as Milan and Mayfield to the unrestricted unincorporated area of Sumner County.Afterwards, Lynda Davis said she and her family does not know what they are going to do next. They said to move the mobile homes to another location under the Sumner County guidelines would cost them $8,000 and they don’t have the money. They now worry about being homeless.
read more